GTA 6, and parenting teens when things go wrong
Ask Rachel anything In this week’s Wonder Room, Katharine Radice and I tackle three very different parenting dilemmas. The launch of GTA 6, how to cope as a parent when something awful happens to our child, and how to ask questions that get our teens connecting and talking. They all have something important in common: how do we move away from fear and control, towards wonder, curiosity, connection and trust? For all of the tips from this episode join our community by clicking here ...
In this week’s Wonder Room, Katharine Radice and I tackle three very different parenting dilemmas. The launch of GTA 6, how to cope as a parent when something awful happens to our child, and how to ask questions that get our teens connecting and talking.
They all have something important in common: how do we move away from fear and control, towards wonder, curiosity, connection and trust?
For all of the tips from this episode join our community by clicking here
GTA 6: Start with your values, not the pressure from other parents
When your child says everyone else is playing GTA 6, it’s easy to feel pressured into saying yes. It’s very like the pressure we experience when our children start begging for a phone, so I thought it might be useful to help you think through the problem by stepping back from the noise and searching inside your own value system.
But before making a decision, ask yourself: What kind of person am I trying to raise?
Of course, just because you hope your child turns out to be a certain type of adult there’s no guarantee, indeed trying to control who they become can backfire. And yet, unless we have clear values in our own heads it’s going to be impossible to have healthy conversations with our children about why we’re making the decisions we’re making. It also makes it harder for us to spot why we feel uncomfortable when they’re asking for something we don’t like.
Think about your family values around violence, drugs, the treatment of women, responsibility, friendships and belonging. If we say one thing then freely allow them to consume content that contradicts what we’re saying, it’s going to muddy the waters.
As Katharine puts it, “Your brain eats what you feed it.”
There is a middle path, which gamer and digital trauma specialist, Catherine Knibbs explains in our interview about how to support our children as they venture into what she calls the ‘Digital City Park’.
Her suggestion is that if you’re considering allowing an age-inappropriate game, explore its content yourself first and decide where the restrictions should be. Consider playing alongside your teenager and discussing what they’re seeing. It’s also best if games can be played in a public area so they’re not hidden from sight.
If you decide against it, explain your reasoning rather than simply imposing a ban, and let them know that you realise there’s a chance they might be exposed to it at someone else’s house and you’re open to having conversations about what they think.
For all of the tips from this episode click here
Please hit the follow button if you like the podcast, and share it with anyone who might benefit.
You can review us on Apple podcasts by going to the show page, scrolling down to the bottom where you can click on a star then you can leave your message.
Please don't hesitate to seek the advice of a specialist if you're not coping. There's no shame in reaching out for support. When you look after yourself your entire family benefits.
Find all the tips from the episode on Substack:
My email teenagersuntangled@gmail.com
My website has a blog, searchable episodes, and ways to contact me
Well, hello again, and welcome to the bonus episode Wonder Room where we parents try to become more fearless, fearless, and wonder more. I'm Rachel Richards and we're joined again by my anchor in the parenting storm, Catherine Rodice, author, teacher, pastor or head, and mother of two teenagers. Hi Catherine.
SPEAKER_01Hello.
SPEAKER_00Now today we are going to talk about GTA 6. We have a question from a listener about how we parents cope when things go horribly wrong for our older kids. And then I think we should just talk about those questions that we can ask teens that actually work to get them talking. Because that was a really interesting episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_01It was so good.
SPEAKER_00Let's just look at the GTA 6. And I had a great nugget lined up about how hard I've been finding it to step back and let our older kids fail. And then I thought, you know, I don't think that's the best way to serve the community when we've just had this massive launch of Grand Theft Auto 6. And I like to stay in my lane. I'm not a gamer. So initially I thought I don't have much to say about it. But I have interviewed Catherine Nibbs, who is a gamer and a specialist on in online trauma. And I think about things in a similar way to the way she does. I will put the link to that interview in the podcast notes. Here's my penny's worth. In the UK, GTA 6 is registered as an 18-plus game. But there are parents giving kids as young as 11 access. And that means kids are coming home at that sort of age, or you know, maybe 14, complaining that they're being left out because other kids are playing the game. And I get it. And I thought about it and I thought, well, I don't have a lot to say about gaming and about the game itself, but I think it's a bit like the phone problem. So I wanted to talk about how we can think this through. And I'm never going to tell you what to do. That's the whole point about this podcast. Because I don't live in the same neighborhood as you. I don't have the same physical or financial constraints as you. I'm not having to negotiate parenting with your partner. And I don't have the same kids. I'm a pragmatist and I know that we're all dealing with different pressures. So I just thought, let's model how we can think this through. So my answer is let's start with the values. What's your end game? What kind of human are you trying to raise? Do you want them to be hardworking? Do you want them to have healthy ideas about women? What about your attitude to drug taking, upholding good community values, staying inside the law? Is really important that they have fun with their friends and they're not excluded and that they need to be popular. Like what is important to you? I think you need to know and you need to sit with yourself and really understand that because the things we allow our children to do and the environment that they're immersed in will shape their ideas about what is normal and what is acceptable. And Catherine, I asked you, do your boys game? And you said no. Why is that, do you think?
SPEAKER_01It's an interesting question. In fact, I asked one of my sons just the other night why he thought he'd never really got into gaming. Because although my older child did a little bit of, you know, Minecraft and I think it was bed wars, way back, you know, kind of five years ago, neither of them have gamed in a big way. And I said to my younger son, why do you think you don't? And he said, Well, mum, I just never got into it. And then when I was old enough to think about getting into it more, I kind of looked to the sides and I realised I didn't want to. And I think part of that was when they were younger, they just didn't have the devices. You know, it just was never part of their world. And so when they then kind of felt more of the social pressure around them, other people gaming at school, I think they found it a bit easier to say no, perhaps, because they knew that if they were going to be gaming for hours and hours and hours, then they wouldn't be doing the sort of things that they valued doing already. But I completely appreciate it is a huge challenge as parents when suddenly a massive thing happens, like the release of this game, everyone's talking about it. And are you gonna let your child be part of it or not? It's a really, really difficult decision. But I think I totally share your concerns. And you know, one of our big things at home has always been the principle of your brain eats what you feed it. So you kind of have to think, what diet are my kids going to be eating? And one of the difficult things about video games is they are so immersive and they can last for so long. There's a huge question of do I want that sort of stuff going into their brains at a really formative age? Which has two questions, right? You know, there's the do we have it and how long do they play for? But it does take a bit of thought, I think. It's really, really tricky.
SPEAKER_00And and I'm coming back to this whole point of values because actually some of our listeners are gonna be avid gamers, and I've got friends whose husbands were avid gamers, even though they weren't gamers, and they love it. And I can absolutely see that that would be a value to them. So I'm never gonna say, Oh, you shouldn't be gaming, because who am I to say what people should be doing? It's a massive industry. There are kids going into gaming and making money out of it. So my point is coming back to your values, know who you are, because now you can talk to your child about the decisions that you are making. So that could be, I don't care, they can take time off school to play as much as they want. But if you do that, you've got to be aware of the message that you're telling them about their schooling, about their place in society, about their responsibilities to teachers and their other classmates. If they, you know, like half the class is missing on a day when they're all gaming. Um, what's going to happen to that sort of environment? And, you know, whether they turn up for other people, you might decide that you want them to have access to the game, but you'd like to have input on what they see and to be able to coach and mentor them through the game. So I know a number of people who are either into gaming or perhaps just trying to be really cons conscientious parents might get the game for a younger person and sit there with them, which is what Catherine Nibb says you should do, it and go through the stages. Now you could actually play it first and then think, oh no, no, no, I don't want them doing this and I don't want them doing that, which is one valid way of dealing with particular games, or you could sit with them side by side and talk them through what they're seeing and look at their reaction. How are they receiving this and say, do you think that that's okay that somebody would treat a woman like that? What, you know, how does that compare to what you think would be acceptable in real life, for example? Or, you know, these people all seem to be taking drugs. Because the problem is if we're not with them when they're doing this or when they're receiving this information, we can't unpack it with them. And I also think we can actually have public spaces in our homes, maybe the kitchen. So when my kids did start using computers, I kept the kit the computer in the kitchen, so everybody in the house was walking past when they were using it, so you could see what was going on. So that was another healthy way of being involved in what they were doing. And I think if you they are, if you're refusing to allow them to play the game again, totally valid, knowing that their friends might be playing the game, again, you can talk to them about the values. Like, why is it that you think that this is not an acceptable thing or you can't endorse them playing this game at that age? Because when a teenager understands the reasons why you're making the decisions you you're making, then they're going to be much more comfortable with being able to square it with themselves. And I used to say to my daughters all the time, you know, I would love to give you access to XYZ. I'd like to say yes, it would be the easiest thing in the world, but I'm not going to, because I'm your parent and I don't think it's good for you. And they they understood that. So that's one of the ways that we can actually deal with this in a healthy way. Kathleen, what's your nugget for this week?
SPEAKER_01Ooh, my nugget. Well, I've had quite an interesting week because earlier this week I was up at the Girls School Association Head Teachers Conference, which is a gathering with lots of heads from across lots of girls' schools up and down the country. And one of the speakers they had was a lady called Diana Asagi, who is an inspirational head teacher. She's run some really, really tough London schools, the the the sorts of schools which are, in her own words, you know, have the kids that no other school wants, you know. So she's really, really tough. She's really strong, inspirational leader. And she was doing a session for all the heads in the room about handling difficulty. And one of her points was the idea of the internal soundtrack in your own head. You know, what do you say to yourself to get yourself going? And she said, you know, she's worked really hard on a positive internal soundtrack. And I think, you know, we all sort of know the importance of speaking kindly to her to ourselves. But the bit she said that's my nugget, the bit that really got me thinking, was she said, we have to hear not just the words we say to ourselves, but the tone we say them in.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Because she said she has a habit of saying to herself things like, Come on, Diana, you can do
SPEAKER_00this.
SPEAKER_01But she says it in quite an angry way, you know, come on, you can do this, you know. And it really made me think that so much of our conversation isn't just about the words we say, but the tone we say it in. And it's made me quite a lot more mindful in my conversations with my husband, my children, you know, with people I teach, colleagues and so on, just to think what is the tone I'm using. Oh, I
SPEAKER_00love that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Or what tone am I hearing in them? And if the tone seems angry or off or you know irritable, are we just checking that we've heard the tone right? Are we checking that we're saying it in the way we want to? Because so often where we get cross, it's not really the words, it's the tone and the flavour. So yeah. Big shout out for Diana.
SPEAKER_00Um it's very easy for us to misread things. And it's also things like if your child tells you something, you could say, I I know. Or you could say, Oh, I know. And the difference in the way the tone feels in those two comments is massive. So I I love that. I think that's really, really important. Um
SPEAKER_01and I think also sometimes with our teens, you know, we we react to tone in a way that's negative. We even when our teen is trying to do the right thing.
SPEAKER_00So
SPEAKER_01I was thinking about, you know, chores, like so much of family chat is about, are you gonna do this? Have you done this? You know, all of that. And if I say to one of my boys, you know, can you take the dogs out? And they say, Yeah, fine. And what I hear is an angry tone, and I think, oh, you know, you've been a bit
SPEAKER_00dismissive. You've been
SPEAKER_01pearlish, you know, exactly,
SPEAKER_00exactly.
SPEAKER_01And you know, I might get her rumpity, but the fact is what they've actually said to me is yes, fine. And they probably did feel a bit annoyed that they had to do it, but from their point of view, they are trying to get it right and they're saying yes. And therefore, I think, although you know it's a good thing as a parent to kind of just mention, oh, you know, your your tone sounds a bit prickly, you know, you might want to say it in a you know different sort of way, but actually to make sure that we aren't judging our children on their tone alone, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Because
SPEAKER_01it's quite hard for a teenager to get their tone right. And actually, if they've said, okay, I'll do it, even if the tone seemed a bit off, actually giving them sometimes the benefit of the doubt and thinking what they were trying to do was say yes, and maybe their feelings were a bit kind of top-heavy, and that's you know, knocked us a bit. But actually, let's give them the benefit of the doubt wherever we can.
SPEAKER_00It's a classic, don't take it personally.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Now we have a question, and I'm just just gonna make it clear that I remove details uh when people write questions like this because I don't want to identify people. Um this is from a wonderful loyal member of our community. She wrote, My daughter, who's nearly 19, was sexually assaulted by a male who she thought was a best friend when she visited him at his university. My goodness, the poor girl. In the moment it sounds like she froze and was too awkward to do anything, and she was also alone. So the question that was asked, and I'm only going to focus on that question because this is a massive topic. So her question was, how do you, the parent, manage that situation? So, how do we as parents manage our own failures in perhaps not giving enough information, not protecting your child from themselves? How do you manage a young adult who is walking into situations unprepared and doesn't want to acknowledge your concerns and you can't stop them? And she goes on to say, I am now genuinely terrified. So I love that she's honest with herself. She's having lots of conversations about consent boundaries. She said, I thought parenting was going to get easier as they got older. Yes, I agree. And she said, now I'm also managing my husband who feels like he should increase control because he doesn't trust her decisions anymore. So wow. Um yeah, and I just want to say I'm really sorry that you're in this situation. And I'm not going to get into the consent points, uh, but we can just start by making it clear that this girl did nothing wrong. As a parent, we need to look at facts, not just at our feelings. She was visiting a guy she thought was her best friend, even if he wasn't her best friend and she was visiting him. He doesn't have a right to her body. But, you know, let's not get into the whole that whole topic because that's a whole thing of itself. There's a fantastic organization called IhatheRight2.org, and I'll put the link in the notes, and they cover everything from how to coach your child against sexual assault to what to do if they do tell you about an assault. And the thing I'll draw out from it is the acronym ABLE, which is affirm, remind them that you love them because victims often feel unworthy of love. But believe them. We don't need to interrogate them. Often the details can be fuzzy. So you you don't need to kind of get down to the nitty-gritty, just believe that it's not their fault and that they don't deserve it and tell them that. And then let them lead the conversation and listen with you know with intent. You don't have to have a fix-it, and then only extend what you can. So you can say, we're going to get through this together. And I would say that there's a parallel here with what happened with my daughter, Phoebe. You know, everybody who's been listening for a while will know she suffered horrendous burns from a burst hot water bottle. And I could have been upset when I heard about it. Like, why didn't you call the water before putting it in and hating myself for not warning her enough? Like, did I tell her enough times? But but the the bottle burst. It wasn't anyone's fault except the bottle. And that wouldn't change anything. So her first response was to ruminate on why she made the decision she did. So she felt shame and she started talking about what she could have or should have or you know, didn't. And I knew that that would could potentially damage her. So I realized my job was to help her move through the pain and help her recover without making her responsible for my own fear and guilt. And that pain is real. So when she was tearful and she said, I don't know why I'm so upset, I told her it's completely reasonable to feel upset. You this is the right response. And that's something like, is my child responding in an appropriate way? Yes, for sure she is. And I'd say for parents, it's so, so difficult to accept that we can't guarantee our child's safety. I mean, we're living in an era of safety, safetyism, aren't we? How can I protect my child? There's so much more of it now than there ever was before. And I think that fear makes us want to control. And I've seen that in the past with my husband, where his reaction was to shut everything down. Totally understandable. But if our response is to something terrible happening, is to now reduce their freedom. Our child might think that being honest with us just leads to punishment, which could mean she's less likely to come to us with problems in the future, right? So I I think we can discuss practical arrangements for visits, accommodation, transport. And I think one of the other things she raised was the fact that she sees risk now that her daughter doesn't, but she's 18. 19, nearly 19. There's a limited amount that we can do to prevent our adult children from making uh bad decisions. And there's a brilliant psychologist, Alfred Adler, who's talked about in The Courage to Be Disliked, is a brilliant best-selling book. So get it, it's a brilliant book. And he talks about the separation of tasks, and we need to look at something, any situation. So for this situation, we have to say who ultimately suffers the consequences of a decision this person makes. And then we have to know that that's the person who ultimately has responsibility. And we can't control that, right? And I think maintaining friendships and visiting university friends, they're not reckless choices. They're really, really good things, even after she's had an assault. And I think we can't protect our children from everything, even though we want to. We want them to be bruised, not scarred. And I think that if someone has done something bad, the best response we can do is not let it define us, not turn it into a horrendous scarf that they think of for the rest of their life. And they will see it that way if we treat it like a scar. So we need to help them see it as a bruise and help them to heal it.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I think, I think as parents, you know, we often have to go back to really fundamental questions. So a bit like you were saying with Grand Theft Auto, you know, we have to go back to our fundamental values and our fundamental questions. And one of the fundamental questions as a parent is is my job to try and make sure my child has a route through life where nothing bad ever happens, or is my job to be by their side to help them through when things happen which are difficult? And although we might crack a route for our kids that is free from any sort of problem, it's just not possible. You know, whatever we do as a parent, sometimes, you know, the cruel wind of fortune blows against us and something happens which is entirely unexpected. You know, your daughter went off to university to stay with a friend, you know, you that that is absolutely not, on the face of it, a high-risk situation. It went wrong in a way that was really unexpected. But you can't rule that out. So instead, the question has to be okay, well, I have to accept, difficult though it is, that sometimes horrible things happen, and my heart goes out to the daughter and my heart goes out to the parent. But at the same time, to help her through this, I kind of think we have to have at the forefront of our minds do we want a young person to believe there's a route through, to value themselves, to trust themselves, to still have hope that the world is a place full of people who are nice and kind, as well as some people who do terrible things. Or do we not? And the risk is if as parents we suddenly try and swoop in and say, right, we need to close down this opportunity and you can't do that, and you made a bad judgment call, so we now need to make more judgments on your behalf. You know, I 100% understand the impetus behind that, but the net result is that we treat the teen like they are weaker, more foolish, less trustworthy, that the world is nothing but danger, like people are nothing but threat. And I don't think that version of the world helps a teenager grow and thrive.
SPEAKER_00So
SPEAKER_01I'd say to any parent in this position, you know, take a deep breath, be there for the tears, be as compassionate as you can, but try and hold back from the sulda woulda coulda.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Because you never get back to that shoulda woulda coulda world. Instead, try and face forward and think, how do we rebuild strength and hope as opposed to live in a very, very brittle world of fear? But as I say, my heart goes out because it is difficult, difficult times when a curveball like this lands. It's really destabilizing and it's really difficult.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's these things that are completely unexpected, they just come out of nowhere and you suddenly have to cope. And nobody really prepares you for this stuff because it's, you know, as they get older, they're going off like that wonderful quote about how when we have a baby, um, suddenly a bit of our heart is walking around in the world and and we have no control over it, but our heart is still in there. But are you like, no, I don't want my child to be hurt, this is horrible. So I totally understand this desire to keep her safe. But the truth is she is going to have to navigate all sorts of things in her life. So learning that she can make choices, she is empowered, it's got to be a the better way through this, hasn't it? And we've just got to, whenever something suddenly happens, take just a pause, take a pause and just go, okay, I need to separate out whose responsibility this is to get through this. My job is to be the mentor and to help carry the pain until they can pick it up again. So my whole thing with Phoebe, I'm just going to carry everything for her, not dwell too much on anything until she's got back on her feet again and then she's back at university having a great time. Anyone who's asking, she's having a wonderful time.
SPEAKER_01I think parenting is so full of fear. You know, one of the reasons I like this podcast is because of the title Fearless and Wonder Ball, because I do think as parenting, quite a lot of it is a dance in dealing with our fear. So, for example, I live in Cambridge, right? And in Cambridge, people cycle everywhere because it's flat as a pancake. But it also means there are quite a lot of bike accidents. And I would say pretty much once a year in the school, the, you know, whatever school I'm teaching at, once a year, someone in that school community will have a bike accident, which is sometimes, you know, a bit bad, and sometimes it has been really bad. And so every time my boys leave the house and go cycling, there's then Little bit of me that's saved. I can imagine.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that kid. Yes.
SPEAKER_01Genuinely, if they are that kid, if today is the day where they get knocked off their bikes and they're boys, they cycle, you know, far too fast from my point of view. But equally, they are boys on their bikes making their decisions. They've had the speed lecture from me. And you know, I do have that fear of what happens if today is the day they come home, they've been knocked off. You know, will I be able to forgive myself for letting them cycle and so on? But the fact is, if I listen to that fear and say to them, you can't ever get on a bike because there is this risk that something awful happens to you, that would be no life for them.
SPEAKER_00No,
SPEAKER_01and
SPEAKER_00no joy. There's no joy in life when we see it that way.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And I also think sometimes, you know, we can make good decisions that have bad outcomes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So going to visit a friend at university at the point where someone makes that decision, it can be a good decision at the point where she makes it, because it came from a place of, you know, I like my friend, I want to visit them, I know him, you know, all of these things. A decision can come from a good place, and then it can have a bad outcome because of things that were unforeseen and not known. But that doesn't mean the fundamental decision-making capacity has gone wrong. And a message I quite often work with young people on is judge your decisions by the reasons that went into them.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Not just by their outcomes. Otherwise, we end up doubting ourselves sometimes in a way that is unfair. But it is tricky. It is tricky. No, I love that.
SPEAKER_00That's I think that's brilliant. Yes. Um, right, should we talk about asking questions? Better questions. Asking better questions, not things like how was school? Because how how much do our kids want to answer that question? Not at all. Uh what did you think about Andy Nadler and his Food for Thought ideas?
SPEAKER_01I thought it was brilliant. I thought it was absolutely brilliant, and actually also well-timed for a week where GTA is coming out. Because one of the things that was so reassuring was I thought, you know, here we have a normal guy with a normally normal family life where his kids have been watching YouTube, and you know, he's gaming and they're gaming, and you know, all of us parents who are thinking, oh, are we getting the screen thing right? And actually to listen to someone who said, Well, you know, screens are there in our family, but then I started to think maybe things in the family are going not quite as we want. So here is a positive change that they made midstream. And his idea that actually, if they had as a sacrosanct thing, that every night round the dinner table they would talk about something interesting, then actually you grow something lovely, which is a real mitigator for whatever else might be happening in the bits of your kids' life that you can't directly control. If every night they sit around the table and they have a chat about something interesting and the adults in their life take their opinions seriously, that's huge. That's so enabling for kids. And it's good for the way they think, it's good for their articulacy, but it's also, I think, really good for their self-worth.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Just to think that their words are of interest to someone else is really good for self-worth. But his fundamental point that if you ask boring questions, you get boring answers. And if you ask more interesting questions, then you get more interesting answers. I mean, you know, it sounds so simple when he says it that way, but it's it's kind of, you know, life-changing. It's brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.
SPEAKER_00Same with me. And it's interesting because I mean, I think round the table is a brilliant time to do it. And I'm a big fan of always having meals together around the table. I realize that some people, that's just not going to happen. It depends on what your work schedules are like, it depends on what your physical setup at home is like. Because my daughter was on a sort of biology field trip three days last week, and the first day I needed to give her a lift to college. And so while we're in the car, I thought we could just sit here or I could ask her a good question. So I just said to her, if you could be an expert in anything tomorrow and you wouldn't have to do any extra work or anything, what would it be? And she told me, Oh, um, I think I'd want to be um a NASA expert and be an astronaut. Wow.
SPEAKER_01And
SPEAKER_00I just like, what? Like, where sorry, where did that come from? And then we had this whole conversation about things that she'd been researching. And I thought, wow, I absolutely would have missed that. I absolutely would have missed that interest of her, because she doesn't talk about these things with me normally. And then the next day I actually opted to give her a lift, even though I had said I'm not going to give you a lift today. And I on the way there, I said, you know, I chose to come in the car with you because I I like her. It's funny. She was like, Oh, really? And yeah, yeah, yeah. And then um that that day I said, if you were in government and you got the choice to fix education, what would you start with? And she said, I would start with GCSEs, the exams you take at 16. And I said, Oh, really? Why was that? I know she hated GCSEs. And she just said, Oh, because science was so boring and we I broadened the curriculum, so there were things for everybody to study. Fair point, very expensive, not gonna happen. I just thought, gosh, it gives you a chance to probe the way that they think in a way that comes at it a completely different way. And I find that absolutely fascinating. But then I also asked the next day, if you could have any mentor in the world, that could be someone you know now or just someone who's at a distance, who would it be? Absolutely fell flat, wasn't interested in the question at all. I
SPEAKER_01think with these questions, we could be quite, you know, easy come, easy go. Because the whole point of an interesting question is not that your kid has to be interested in that question, but if we just try different questions and then when we find a question that they are interested in, then you know, happy days. But as I was listening to him, I did think the only bit that I'd possibly slightly kind of add to is, you know, he was super keen on the idea that questions need to be interesting, and you know, yes, they absolutely do. But one of the things that makes a teen open up is when the question is safe,
SPEAKER_00and quite a lot
SPEAKER_01of the questions we ask our teens don't feel very safe. Because if you know our kids come home and we say, How was school? That doesn't feel like a safe question. Because if the answer is terrible, then we as parents probably have quite a big reaction. And if we say, Have you done your homework? and the answer is no, then again, as parents, we probably kind of go into that, and why not? And you know, blah, blah, blah. So the sort of questions that often work are the questions where a teen knows that they are free for their answer to be whatever it is, without the parent having a whole load of judgment about that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I love that.
SPEAKER_01And when I first started teaching, you know, I taught in boarding schools at the start of my career. And if you teach in boarding schools, there's a lot of time when you are with young people, but you're not in a formal lesson. So it means as a teacher, you have to have two modes. You have to have the mode of, you know, here I am in the classroom and everyone's quiet and listening and I'm driving everything. And then there's the, you know, I'm supervising free time in the boarding house where there still needs to be interaction, but it's not quite the same mode. So I realised early on, right, I've got to learn how to generate conversation out of nowhere.
SPEAKER_00Amazing.
SPEAKER_01So these interactions can happen. And way back then, this is 20 years ago, but one of my favourite questions used to be for the kids who would win in a fight. Now, I'm not recommending that they should suddenly start fighting, but things like, you know, if you had Winston Churchill versus Julius Caesar, you know, who would win in a fight? And I think one of the reasons why the question used to work so well, because I used to have all these boys around the table kind of debating who'd win in a fight. And I think one of the reasons it worked is that they knew that I was not at any advantage in my fighting knowledge. Right. So their version of who would win in a fight, you know, they had expertise and they had information they could bring. And they used to love it. And we used to riff around, you know, stuff like that. So, you know, as a parent, asking questions where the kid doesn't think that we're gonna think we have a better answer lined up in advance,
SPEAKER_00yeah, that's quite a big
SPEAKER_01thing.
SPEAKER_00So good.
SPEAKER_01Because if you it makes such a difference. If you ask a question where your kid thinks, actually, I the child am in either an equal or a superior position of knowledge, or it just doesn't matter what my answer is, so I can go anywhere. Those are the safe questions where it's easier for the teen to show a bit of themselves because every time you put your idea out there, you are showing a bit of yourself. And it's possible with that mentor question that you know, either Amelia was just too tired, or possibly, you know, who do you want to mentor you gets a little bit close to what's your career gonna be? Is it on track? What skills do you want to build?
SPEAKER_00Because then she asked me back, she went, Well, who would you choose?
SPEAKER_01And I
SPEAKER_00thought, well, I don't
SPEAKER_01know.
SPEAKER_00What's your answer? I don't I'm gonna really portray myself here. I was like, Katherine Ryan or Marina Hyde. And I I love both those women because they're both strong, they're both compassionate, but they're really funny and they're really incisive in completely different ways. And I gave that turn and she went, Yeah. Just made me laugh. She's like, she's not impressed by me at all, which is fine. I think your observation is so smart, and I think that's absolutely right. We don't want to make them feel like they're being led some down some route that they don't want to go down. And Jules the Gardener on Threads left a fantastic review, and then she also said, Yesterday I changed my usual questions about school to if you could be any type of potato dish, what would you be?
SPEAKER_01She
SPEAKER_00said, surprisingly, it got my giant team really interested in answering. And he said he'd be chips because then he could form an army. I'm just thinking, just imagining all these all these chips lining up to save us. Like so, so brilliant. And in another
SPEAKER_01the mashed potato.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no, absolutely. Yeah, mashed potato is not going to do
unknownit,
SPEAKER_00unless you're gonna be suffocated by it. Um, and I got another message by email from Uschki Schwager. Um, I hope I pronounced that right, uh, who's a German and she's been living in Italy for 30 years. So she said, first of all, thank you so much for your podcast. Every episode is interesting and helpful. Last episode made me really enthusiastic and I wanted to order the deck, but what a delusion. They don't ship outside the US. Damn.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00I know. I knew I should
SPEAKER_01have to ship it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I should have said that. I actually asked him. I did ask him. And I he said, yeah, he tried to ship to Canada, but the the rates were so high, the tax, blah, blah, blah, blah. So he ships in the US. I'm so sorry. I know I've got listeners all over the world. So what I am doing is on Substack in my little tools box, I'm going to put all my, I know they're budget basement. I'm sorry, I'm not, I'm not as skilled as he is, but I'm going to put all my questions at work in the toolbox. So you can just go in there and ask some. And if you send me in ones that you thought, oh, that worked really well, my kids love that, then we can just gather them together. You know, do a community question bank, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Great idea. And the questions could be big or small. You know, some of the best questions are the totally trivial ones. Because, you know, if it's totally trivial, you can just have some fun with it. And one of the best things you can do in family dialogue is if you can get to a point where people are laughing and enjoying a conversation being a little bit silly, then again it's so freeing because we have to remember that for our kids, quite often when they speak, they're up for judgment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Either because they're speaking to their friends, and when you are a teenager, you know, there's always that slight kind of fear of are my friends going to like me? Are they not? Are they going to react well or badly to what I say? Or a teen is speaking in class when they are definitely up for judgment because the teacher is in some level going to assess what they say. And so actually being able to talk at home in a way that is trivial sometimes. I had a parent once who was really worried about his son being unhappy at school. And he was really worried that his son was not working well. And I was working with him and I said, Okay, so what do you talk about at home? And the dad said, Well, you know, I ask him about his homework and his lessons, but he never wants to talk about that. And I said, I said I said to the dad, So what do you think he does talk about? And the dad said, The only thing he ever wants to talk about is football. And I said, Well, just talk about football. Just talk about football. Don't worry about trying to talk about the lessons and whatever. Because if you are trying to build conversation, talk about the stuff that is easiest and lightest and most natural. And then as the conversation builds, it will be easier to get the harder stuff in. But you kind of need that pattern of we can talk to each other in a way that's calm and fun and supportive and not too heavy. That rhythm needs to exist if it's going to feel safe enough to talk about the stuff that's a bit harder.
SPEAKER_00That's what they say in the disengaged teen. Being able to completely relax and have fun and also engage in hobbies or things that interest them is it it makes home be a completely different safe place. And I think that that's such a valuable thing to talk about, Catherine. I love that point.
SPEAKER_01I came across a um a super interesting idea this week, or at least an idea that was just verbalized really, really well. Um I was talking to Laura Earnshaw, who runs a company called My Happy Mind, which does mental health training for kids, predominantly in primary schools, but also now secondary. You know, she works with thousands, literally thousands of schools, you know, NHS endorsed. She's a real mover and shaker in the child and adolescent mental health space. And one of her key ideas is that if we want to build self-esteem, then we have to praise character, not competencies. And the risk is as a parent, quite often what we do is we try and either praise competencies or we try and get those competencies to be a bit better. You know, is your mask good enough? Can you tie your shoelaces? What's happening to your football practice? Why aren't you pushing forward with this and so on? And the problem with praising competencies is that it feels very brittle because a child thinks, well, unless I stay being good at that thing or I get better at that thing, then my self-worth erodes. But if we praise character, then that builds a really durable self-esteem because a kid who's kind knows that they can still be kind tomorrow and they can be kind the next day. And what that then opens up is the question of well, if we do want to praise character, we have to give our kids opportunities to show us who they are and what they think and you know what their likes are and what their dislikes are, and you know, what their trivial opinions are, as well as their serious life plans. So, you know, the kind of potato question about chips lining up to go and fight in an army, you know, that question will have done arguably as much good as a serious conversation about whether or not the UCAS statement was ready. There is so much benefit in just talking about anything so that our teens know that someone is interested in them and someone enjoys what they have to say. I think it's huge.
SPEAKER_00Their best friends at any moment in time could decide that they're not friends anymore. It's only in your home that you can ever be sure of unconditional love and unconditional acceptance. That's what a family can offer. And that unconditional love and acceptance really comes through when you can have fun with somebody, when you can when you can just accept them for who they are and you're not trying to steer them in any particular direction. So those moments where you can just be silly, I yeah, they they just were so much. Brilliant. Catherine, that was uh fantastic. Thank you. I love all your tips. I love the people you've been talking to. If you found this useful, give us a review, share it, like it. Tell your friends about it anyway. And um, you can go to Catherine's Substack. It's really, really good. As you can tell, she has all these wonderful tips and wonderful ideas. Catherine, what's your Substack call? How do how do people find you?
SPEAKER_01I have just rebranded it. It's now called Teens and School. And you can find it either by searching for that or by searching for my name on Substack, and it'll pop up easy peasy.
SPEAKER_00Brilliant. And uh, I'm on teenagersuntangled.com. You can message me teenagersuntangled at gmail.com. It's really easy. Just let us know what you think. Good or bad. Any suggestions, any great questions you've asked at work, we want to hear them all. We will read them out on the programme. Uh, that's it for this week. Big hug, bye
SPEAKER_01bye.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed